Marek Siwiec MEP on Poland & Europe

Grass and Israel

I will probably return more than once to the “poem by Günter Grass”. Today I would like to say a few words on the reactions in Israel.

I disapprove of this work and its political message. However, I find Israel’s reaction unfortunate and counterproductive. I understand that Grass was condemned but the ban on crossing this country’s border is totally overeager. If I were in the place of the authorities in Jerusalem, I would do the contrary – I would invite Grass and give him a chance to talk with the public that is the most concerned by this problem. Let him present his arguments to students, intellectuals, to all those who in some time may become the target of Iranian nuclear weapon. I would not discuss with him about his membership in the SS because before he wrote this poem, no one in Israel had problem with that.

And I would also offer him a permanent residence in the Holy Land. If he is so sure about the peaceful intensions of Iran, let him stay for a longer time, because apparently nothing bad would happen to him.

Author :


  1. Polemic nonsense.

    Grass was never a member of the SS but served as a juvenile soldier of the Waffen SS. Of course this has nothing to do with the poem. The disputed message, that he had to overcome self-constraints, was right. The other core message, a political assessment of the current threatening of Iran is shared by many citizens of Israel. Even a Iran in possessiin of nuclear weapons would not attack Israel, the other nuclear power.

    What is questionable is the literary quality of the work.

  2. A single end in the rope was connected for the arm, although another end was just looped spherical a compact hook about the arm – so it came off in the end in the throwing swing. The rope experienced a net, or sling, connected to it – which held a missile. When the trebuchet was fired, the arm flew up, the rope came from the hook plus the missile was thrown at in regards to the time once the arm was vertical.For this reason, she feels closer to Beast, the valet, along with their horses, than she ever must a man. As an alternative to wishing for any soul, she condemns them by calling them “flimsy” and “insubstantial” (165) . She feels the men who declare to possess souls take into account her no over an item of physical really worth..It is specifically an issue with persons who’ve trained prior to, received hurt, misplaced conditioning and now usually are not in the very same situation they had been prior to they stopped. They feel they can’t go back again until they’re bodily back again to their previous situation. That’s a massive error.From its source near Clints Well up about the Mogollon Rim to where it enters the Verde River beneath Camp Verde, West Clear Creek winds for nearly forty miles by several of the most stunningly lovely terrain in Arizona. In its higher 30 miles, the part that is definitely specified wilderness, West Clear Creek is completely canyon-bound, offering access to only the couple of plus the hardy. Since it travels for the Verde River, West Clear Creek passes by soaring cliffs of creamy Coconino sandstone and vermilion Supai siltstone, which lend their colours for the narrows called the White and Red Bins.Check drinking water periodically to avoid scorching. Add a great deal more drinking water if required. Baste with turkey baster just about every 15 to twenty minutes.

Comments are closed.